Skip to main content
McMaster University
DeGroote School of Business
McMaster University
Search

DSB Main Website Search

McMaster Menu
DeGroote Menu
  • Home
  • Programs
  • About
    • About DeGroote
    • Our Leadership
    • Dean’s Corner
    • McLean Centre for Collaborative Discovery
    • Our Faculty & Research  
    • Strategic Plan 
    • Annual Report 
  • Events
  • Students
    • Student Resources
    • Student Clubs
    • Submit a Student Bulletin
    • Submit your Event
  • Alumni
    • Alumni Resources
    • Wayne C. Fox Distinguished Alumni Award 
    • DeGroote Alumni Social Impact Award
  • Staff
  • Give
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • DeGroote Directory
Search McMaster Menu
  • Home
  • Programs
  • About
    About DeGrooteOur LeadershipDean’s CornerMcLean Centre for Collaborative DiscoveryOur Faculty & Research  Strategic Plan Annual Report 
  • Events
  • Students
    Student ResourcesStudent ClubsSubmit a Student BulletinSubmit your Event
  • Alumni
    Alumni ResourcesWayne C. Fox Distinguished Alumni Award DeGroote Alumni Social Impact Award
  • Staff
  • Give
  • Contact
    Contact UsDeGroote Directory

RESEARCH   STAFF  

In the News: From Trump to Putin: Why are People Attracted to Tyrants?

July 29, 2022 ·

Contributed by: The Conversation

Share

Twitter Facebook LinkedIn Mail Copy Link
A person grips a string of wooden sticks, symbolizing the complexities of power and attraction to authoritarian figures.

Testimony to the House of Representatives’ Jan. 6 committee about the insurrection at the United States Capitol in 2021 has allowed us to delve deeper into the humanity of Donald Trump’s supporters.

As the hearings reveal, the outgoing president and his supporters seemed to be on the same wavelength as he hesitated to stop the violence while his followers were hell-bent on doing his bidding.

Given his influence, it seems clear that Trump knows what makes his followers tick. The allure of Trump’s populism isn’t an isolated phenomenon, but something connected to the way people think about their leaders.

Trump’s populism has now become bigger than Trump himself. The success of tyrants worldwide suggests that we should take them more seriously when they’re praised as smart, at least when it comes to manipulating our minds.

 

The new authoritarianism

Although populist movements have been around a long time, there has been considerable interest in explaining why populism is different now — why it’s paired with authoritarianism and unapologetically tinged with nationalism and xenophobia.

The emotions underlying the passions of disenfranchised masses are rooted today in an us-versus-them fear of national demise — that increasing immigration, liberalization and globalization are damning signs that once-trusted institutions can no longer protect our collective well-being.

In many countries where authoritarianism has gathered steam — Russia, Belarus, Hungary, Turkey and Poland to name a few — this populism is also accompanied by a push by leaders to suppress press freedom or spread rampant misinformation aided by social media.

In a nod to the cleverness of such autocrats, Nobel laureate Maria Ressa describes the political use of such misinformation as “diabolically brilliant.”

Ressa, a journalist, was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize for her efforts to safeguard freedom of expression.

 

Examining the roots of tyranny

Years before Trump’s rise to power, we started to investigate these elements to understand how they drive people’s tolerance of tyranny. We began with a simple premise: that the appeal of tyrants is not an aberration, but a phenomenon tied to how our minds work.

Tyranny, however, is distinct from authoritarianism, which speaks to political beliefs or actions. The defining features of tyrannical leadership — traits described as domineering, pushy, manipulative, loud, conceited and selfish — are prototypical characteristics that catch followers’ attention in the absence of more substantive information about what the leader is really like.

Angry aggressive leader interviewed by media, he is shouting into microphones

As Trump rose to power, elements of our research were playing out in reality: fear of a threatening world, traditional morality — the type commonly expressed in North America through conservative politics and religion — and reliance on scarce information about the leader.

  • Fear is rooted in the sense of needing protection from dangers in the world, and many of our local institutions and their leaders are in fact geared toward ensuring a sense of security.
  • Morality pertains to those visceral convictions that inform many of our daily decisions — for example, whether harm is unfair or rules should be obeyed.
  • Information is associated with the basic fact that we make quick leadership choices based on limited data — we don’t bother to seek more information and we rely on mental shortcuts when judging a leader’s effectiveness.

 

Fear fuels attraction to ‘strongmen’

Based on surveys of 1,147 North Americans, our findings revealed that sensitivity to threats, as reflected in a belief that the world is dangerous, is linked with traditional or conservative morality. American social psychologist Jonathan Haidt calls this morality the “binding moral foundations.”

Those who focus on group protection have a stronger preference for tyranny as defined by the well-established theory of implicit leadership, which says that we don’t always see leaders for who they really are, but according to mental prototypes we have in our heads.

Additionally, we discovered that the significant relationship between the binding foundations and tyrannical leadership is stronger for men than women. It’s no wonder, then, that ardent supporters of Trump throughout his presidency included hypermasculine, anti-feminist, anti-left groups such as the Proud Boys.

Men in baseball caps walk among a crowd. One carries a megaphone.
Proud Boys members walk toward the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021.(AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster)

U.S. author and filmmaker Jackson Katz attributes the overwhelming support of Trump by high-school educated, working-class white men to a deep-seated desire for respect and a return to patriarchy.

The masculine nature of leadership today, especially in times of crisis and uncertainty, has not necessarily changed over the centuries. When bad people show up to invade our fields, corrupt our children or pollute our streams, the gut reaction is to welcome the “strong man” who demonstrates his skills by successfully manipulating others for personal gain.

That means aggression, guile and greed are coveted if those qualities can be turned against outsiders.

 

Fighting tyranny with psychology

Our research suggests that simply railing against tyrants isn’t enough. There are three areas where more action is necessary.

First, the nasty traits of tyrannical leaders send vitally important information about leadership effectiveness to followers — paradoxically, more information than if a leader were to act with kindness and compassion.

The media’s revulsion to tyranny and obsession with reporting every shocking curse or tweet has only served to telegraph those traits far and wide, reinforcing the allegiance of followers.

Second, concerned citizens need to do less recounting of every nasty incident on behalf of tyrants and instead spend a lot more time explaining the nature of good leadership and how it compares with today’s leaders.

Some business schools do a good job of teaching the meaning of sustainable, effective leadership, yet the typical young person gets little education on moral character and the strengths of trustworthy, virtuous leaders of the past.

Third, people’s fears — whether they pertain to economic loss, foreign adversaries or cultural demise — need to be taken seriously. The average person becomes overwhelmed by the sheer magnitude of audacious attempts at social change, as evidenced by the discontent over German leader Angela Merkel’s welcome of Syrian refugees.

A crowd of angry white people, many with their hands raised.
Protesters in eastern Germany demonstrate against Germany’s welcome of immigrants and refugees in 2015.(AP Photo/Jens Meyer)

Such efforts don’t always address the fundamental need for the conservative population to feel safe, because they fail to appreciate that people on both ends of the spectrum share a common desire for the collective good, although they may prioritize aspects of that good differently and approach those aspects via different means.

Elements of everyday human psychology are driving our shared global future. For our societies to survive, the dialogue must change rapidly to address this reality, or else the sole voices we’ll be forced to hear will be those of fear-mongering, war-mongering tyrannical liars.The Conversation

 

Authors: Agata Mirowska, Assistant Professor, Human Resources Management and Organizational Behavior, Neoma Business School; Raymond B. Chiu, Assistant Professor, Business and Organizational Behaviour, Redeemer University, and Rick Hackett, Canada Research Chair, Organizational Behaviour & Human Performance, McMaster University.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Tags:   IN THE NEWS PHD RESEARCH RICK HACKETT

Related Stories

From research to impact: DeGroote undergraduate student research day  
August 20, 2025 · RESEARCH · STRATEGIC PLAN | RESEARCH AND SCHOLARSHIP · STUDENT

From research to impact: DeGroote undergraduate student research day  

Breaking financial barriers: New learning hub explores solutions to address financial exclusion
July 25, 2025 · MCCD · SOCIETAL IMPACT · STRATEGIC PLAN | ENGAGING COMMUNITIES

Breaking financial barriers: New learning hub explores solutions to address financial exclusion

Pursuing doctorates together: A story of academic partnership 
June 18, 2025 · INFORMATION SYSTEMS

Pursuing doctorates together: A story of academic partnership 

The Case for Creative Risk-Taking, Even When the Stakes Are High
May 28, 2025 · STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT

The Case for Creative Risk-Taking, Even When the Stakes Are High

In the news: $4.1 million fines for violations of Canada’s temporary foreign worker program are a ‘drop in the bucket’
January 22, 2025 · HUMAN RESOURCES AND MANAGEMENT · RESEARCH

In the news: $4.1 million fines for violations of Canada’s temporary foreign worker program are a ‘drop in the bucket’

The future of healthcare: Mike Heenan on trends and disruptions
January 22, 2025 · STRATEGIC PLAN | ENGAGING COMMUNITIES · ALUMNI · HEALTH POLICY AND MANAGEMENT

The future of healthcare: Mike Heenan on trends and disruptions

People-focused leadership: Insights from Mike Heenan
January 9, 2025 · STRATEGIC PLAN | ENGAGING COMMUNITIES · ALUMNI

People-focused leadership: Insights from Mike Heenan

In the news: The strike is over – now what?
January 9, 2025 · HUMAN RESOURCES AND MANAGEMENT

In the news: The strike is over – now what?

Student perspective: Driving sustainability in freight transportation
December 11, 2024 · OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT · STUDENT

Student perspective: Driving sustainability in freight transportation

Grad students pitch impactful ideas to drive real change
December 4, 2024 · STUDENT · RESEARCH · OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT · SOCIETAL IMPACT

Grad students pitch impactful ideas to drive real change

The heart of supervision: How Manish Verma shapes future leaders
December 3, 2024 · OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT · RESEARCH · STRATEGIC PLAN | RESEARCH AND SCHOLARSHIP

The heart of supervision: How Manish Verma shapes future leaders

President’s Awards celebrate excellence in graduate supervision
November 20, 2024 · OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT · RESEARCH

President’s Awards celebrate excellence in graduate supervision

DeGroote celebrates 45 years of the PhD program
October 29, 2024 · ALUMNI · RESEARCH · STRATEGIC PLAN | RESEARCH AND SCHOLARSHIP

DeGroote celebrates 45 years of the PhD program

In the news: ‘It’s like a cage’: Foreign workers who quit Canadian Tire speak out about feeling trapped by work permits
October 24, 2024 · HUMAN RESOURCES AND MANAGEMENT

In the news: ‘It’s like a cage’: Foreign workers who quit Canadian Tire speak out about feeling trapped by work permits

In the news: New McMaster program offers help to older rural entrepreneurs
September 25, 2024 · HUMAN RESOURCES AND MANAGEMENT · RESEARCH

In the news: New McMaster program offers help to older rural entrepreneurs

DeGroote School of Business DeGroote School of Business Logo
DeGroote Instagram logo DeGroote Linkedin logo DeGroote Facebook logo DeGroote YouTube Logo DeGroote TikTok Logo
DeGroote Menu

  • Programs
  • About DeGroote
  • Events
  • Student Resources
  • Staff Resources
  • Alumni Resources
  • Give
  • DeGroote Directory
  • Contact Us
  • Faculty & Research  
Hamilton Campus

DeGroote School of Business
McMaster University

1280 Main Street West

Hamilton, Ontario
L8S 4M4
Burlington Campus

DeGroote School of Business
Ron Joyce Centre

4350 South Service Road

Burlington, Ontario
L7L 5R8
AACSB Logo

McMaster University is committed to providing websites that are accessible to the widest possible audience.  

If you require any content on this website in an alternate format, please contact dsbweb@mcmaster.ca and we will respond promptly.

DeGroote Online Privacy Policy

McMaster Brighter World Logo McMaster University - Brighter World Logo
Contact McMaster McMaster Terms & Conditions McMaster Privacy Policy
Secret Link